P
Italian · Ancona, Marche
Brodetto all'Anconetana — Adriatic Fish Stew
Brodetto all'Anconetana is the fish stew of Ancona — different from the Pesarese brodetto (which uses saffron and vinegar) and the Rossinese brodetto (minimalist, with vinegar only). The Anconetana version uses 13 types of fish (one for each apostle, with the thirteenth for Judas), cooked in a very simple tomato and olive oil base with no wine, no vinegar, no saffron — just good tomatoes, olive oil, garlic, and the fish. The complexity comes from the variety of fish, not the seasonings.
‹Swipe for the next dish›
I
The Market List
The benchmark for each ingredient, and who stocks it near you. Tap a stockist to go straight to the product.
400 g
scorpionfish
cleaned and cut into pieces
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
gurnard
cleaned and cut into pieces
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
John Dory
cleaned and cut into pieces
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
sea bass
cleaned and cut into pieces
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
sea bream
cleaned and cut into pieces
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
200 g
grey or red mullet
cleaned and cut into pieces
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
200 g
sole
cleaned, left whole or halved
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
cuttlefish
cleaned, ink sac reserved, cut into rings and pieces
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
squid
cleaned, cut into rings
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
clams
scrubbed
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
mussels
scrubbed and debearded
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
300 g
raw shrimp
shell on
Your own market
300 g
seasonal Adriatic fish (e.g. weever, wrasse, or skate)
cleaned and cut into pieces — the thirteenth species, chosen by the market
Your own market
For the base
120 ml
extra-virgin olive oil
good Marche or central-Italian oil
Your own market
4
garlic cloves
lightly crushed, peeled
Your own market
600 g
ripe fresh tomatoes or good passata
fresh tomatoes peeled and roughly chopped in season; passata out of season
Not yet stocked in British Columbia
1 tsp
fine sea salt
to season; adjust at the end
Your own market
To serve
8
slices of coarse country bread
toasted and rubbed with a cut garlic clove
Your own market
II
The Method
1
Set a wide, heavy pot over medium heat. Pour in the olive oil and add the crushed garlic. Warm gently until the garlic is softened and fragrant but takes no colour — the oil should smell sweet and clean, not sharp.
2
Add the tomatoes or passata. Cook over medium heat, pressing the tomatoes down, until the base has collapsed into a dense, dark-red sauce with no pooling water — roughly 12 to 15 minutes. The oil should begin to separate at the edges, signalling that the water has driven off.
3
Add the cuttlefish (with its reserved ink) and the squid. Shake the pot to distribute; do not stir. Cook, covered, over medium-low heat for 10 to 12 minutes. The cephalopods are ready when they have turned from translucent to an opaque, matte white and the liquid they release has thickened perceptibly — this cephalopod broth is the flavour base on which the entire dish is built, and this is where the dish lives or dies: insufficient time here and the broth will be thin; excessive heat and the cuttlefish will tighten and never soften.
4
Add the firm white fish — scorpionfish, gurnard, John Dory, sea bass, sea bream, and the thirteenth species if firm. Shake the pot to settle the pieces into the broth. Cover and cook for 8 minutes. The flesh should just begin to yield at its thickest point when pressed with a fingertip through the lid-lifted steam — it will finish in the residual heat.
5
Add the delicate fish — sole and mullet — along with the clams, mussels, and shrimp. Shake the pot once more. Cover and cook for 5 minutes. The stew is ready when the clam and mussel shells have opened fully and the shrimp have turned uniformly coral-pink. Discard any shells that have not opened.
6
Taste the broth and correct the salt. The broth should be dense, gelatinous at the lip, and carry the mineral depth of all thirteen species without any single fish dominating. Place a slice of garlic-rubbed toast in each warmed bowl. Bring the pot to the table and ladle directly from it, ensuring each portion receives a representative selection of the thirteen fish.
III
Quality Hierarchy
01
Reserve — Thirteen species sourced the same morning from a single Adriatic landing, including live bivalves and ink-intact cuttlefish; a cold-pressed Marche extra-virgin oil; tomatoes from the garden or a trusted local grower at peak August ripeness.
02
Estate — Eight to ten species from a specialist fishmonger, the selection dictated by the day's catch; a reliable central-Italian extra-virgin olive oil; best-quality passata in place of fresh tomatoes out of season.
03
Market — Six to eight mixed species from a good wet-fish counter; decent supermarket passata; a clean, mild extra-virgin oil. The broth will be less complex but the method remains sound.
04
House — Fewer than six species, tinned tomatoes, and a neutral oil; the result is a serviceable fish stew but no longer brodetto all'Anconetana in any meaningful sense — the doctrine of variety has been conceded.
IV
Sensory Tests
◇Sight. The tomato base has thickened to a dense, oil-separated sauce before any fish is added.
◇Sight. Cuttlefish and squid are fully opaque and the released liquid has visibly thickened the base broth.
◇Touch. Firm white fish yields slightly at its thickest point when pressed — not hard, not flaking apart.
◇Sight. All clam and mussel shells stand open; shrimp are uniformly coral-pink with no grey at the joint.
◇Smell. The pot gives off a dense, saline, oceanic steam — layered, not sharp — when the lid is lifted after the final stage.
◇Where it lives or dies. The cephalopods must cook long enough in the tomato base to release their ink, gelatin, and liquor into the pot — this concentrated broth is the structural foundation of the stew; a thin or hurried base cannot be rescued by any subsequent step.
Pillar V
Cross-cuisine parallels are part of membership.
The dishes this one teaches you, across the cuisines — on every recipe.
Enter · from $49 a year
VI
What to Pour
A dry, neutral, high-acid white wine from the Marche — Verdicchio dei Castelli di Jesi is the regional expression; its saline minerality and firm acidity cut the gelatinous broth without competing with the fish. Pour the same wine at table that was not added to the pot.
The whole pairingPillar VII
Origin and lineage are part of membership.
Where the dish comes from and how it came to be — on every recipe.
Enter · from $49 a year