American

Pimento Cheese

A thick, spreadable mixture of grated sharp cheddar cheese (the sharper the better), diced pimento peppers (the small, sweet, red peppers sold in jars), and mayonnaise. The texture should be rough — grated cheese and diced pepper clearly visible, not smooth or processed. The flavour should be sharp (the cheddar), sweet (the pimento), creamy (the mayo), and optionally spicy (cayenne, hot sauce, or diced jalapeño in many recipes). Some versions add cream cheese for extra creaminess; some add Worcestershire for depth; some add garlic. Every Southern cook has a version and the variations are guarded.

‹Swipe for the next dish›

ServesAbout 500 g of spread — enough for six to eight portions on crackers or four generous sandwiches

Sourced0of 7 in BC

Cook

‹ Previous · Pickled Watermelon Rind|Next · Pompano en Papillote ›

The Market List

The benchmark for each ingredient, and who stocks it near you. Tap a stockist to go straight to the product.

450 g

sharp or extra-sharp cheddar

block, hand-grated on the large holes of a box grater — never pre-shredded

Your own market

120 g

pimento peppers

from a jar, drained and diced — not roasted red peppers from a deli counter

Not yet stocked in British Columbia

120 g

Duke's mayonnaise

or Hellmann's; not Miracle Whip

Your own market

Optional additions

¼ tsp

cayenne pepper

or a few dashes of hot sauce

Not yet stocked in British Columbia

115 g

cream cheese

softened, for extra creaminess

Your own market

1 tsp

Worcestershire sauce

for depth

Not yet stocked in British Columbia

1 clove

garlic

finely grated

Your own market

The Method

Grate the cheddar on the large holes of a box grater into a wide mixing bowl. Pre-shredded cheese contains anti-caking agents that prevent cohesion with the mayonnaise; hand-grated cheese produces a spread that binds correctly. The cheese should lie loose and fluffy in the bowl.

Drain the pimento peppers thoroughly and dice them into pieces no smaller than 5 mm — they must remain identifiable in the finished spread. Add them to the bowl with the grated cheese.

Add the mayonnaise. If using cream cheese, Worcestershire, garlic, or cayenne, add them now. This is where the dish lives or dies: fold everything together with a spatula or by hand, using only as many strokes as are needed to distribute the mayonnaise through the cheese. Stop the moment no dry cheese remains visible. Over-working produces a smooth paste; the correct result is rough and rustic — shreds of cheese and flecks of red pepper clearly visible throughout, the whole just cohesive enough to spread.

Taste and adjust: more cayenne or hot sauce if heat is wanted, more mayonnaise if the spread feels too stiff. The finished spread should be sharp from the cheddar, sweet from the pimento, and creamy from the mayo — three distinct notes in balance. Refrigerate for at least 30 minutes before serving; the spread firms slightly and the flavours knit.

III

Quality Hierarchy

Reserve — Extra-sharp aged cheddar, hand-grated; Duke's mayonnaise; small-batch jarred pimentos; finished with a measured amount of cayenne and a touch of Worcestershire.

Estate — Sharp cheddar, hand-grated; Duke's or Hellmann's mayonnaise; standard jarred pimentos; plain or with hot sauce to taste.

Market — Sharp cheddar, hand-grated; any full-fat mayonnaise; jarred pimentos. Serviceable and honest.

House — Mild cheddar, pre-shredded; any mayonnaise. The anti-caking agents in pre-shredded cheese and the mildness of the cheddar produce a spread that is bland and poorly textured — recognisable, but not the dish.

Sensory Tests

◇Sight. Shreds of grated cheese and distinct flecks of red pimento pepper remain visible throughout the spread — it is rough and particulate, not smooth.

◇Touch. The spread holds its shape on a knife or cracker without running; it is thick and cohesive but not stiff.

◇Smell. The sharp, lactic scent of aged cheddar dominates; a faint sweetness from the pimento is detectable beneath it.

◇Where it lives or dies. The spread lives or dies at the moment of mixing: fold only until the mayonnaise is distributed and stop — one stroke too many and the texture collapses from rough and rustic into smooth paste.

V · Cross-Cuisine Parallels

Welsh rarebit — sharp cheddar worked into a sauce; the British precedent for cheddar made spreadable and intensified French fromage fort — leftover cheeses blended into a spread; the same principle of cheese rendered cohesive and spreadable by an added fat German Obatzda — Bavarian cheese spread bound with butter, seasoned with onion and paprika; the closest European structural parallel, sharing the rough texture and the paprika-family colouring

VI · What to Pour

A cold, dry American lager — the carbonation and mild bitterness cut the richness of the cheddar and mayo without competing with the sweet pimento. Sweet iced tea is the non-alcoholic Southern default and works for the same reason: its gentle sweetness echoes the pimento.

VII · Origin & Lineage

Pimento cheese is Southern American, claimed by the South absolutely regardless of whether its commercial origins were Northern. It appears in Nathalie Dupree's Mastering the Art of Southern Cooking and is documented by John Egerton in Southern Food as a fixture of the Southern table — on crackers, on white bread, on celery, stuffed in jalapeños, melted on burgers, and sold, most famously, at Augusta National during the Masters golf tournament. It is called "the pâté of the South" and "Carolina caviar." Every Southern cook holds a version; the variations are guarded.

Pillars V — VII

The full recipe pages are part of membership.

Cross-cuisine parallels, what to pour, and the dish's origin and lineage — on every recipe.

Enter · from $49 a year

← PreviousPickled Watermelon RindOne standard · no exceptionsNext →Pompano en Papillote