Cooking in

South Australia

Mexican

Chile Caldo — Cuicatlán, Oaxaca

A robust, multi-meat broth from the hot lowland town of Cuicatlán in the Cañada region of Oaxaca, where the cooking tends toward the hearty and unfussy. Beef short ribs, pork knuckles, and chicken pieces are simmered together with a parade of vegetables — pumpkin, fresh corn, chayote, lima beans — and finished with whole ripe chilhuacle chiles that melt into the broth, coloring and flavoring it without being blended away. This is a dish built for a crowd, a Sunday pot, a table that expects to sit for a while.

‹Swipe for the next dish›

Serves6–8

Sourced0 of 10 in SA

Cook

‹ Previous · Chileatole Mixteco (Mixtec Chileatole)|Next · Chile Dulce (Sweet Chile Relish) ›

The Market List

The benchmark for each ingredient, and who stocks it near you. Tap a stockist to go straight to the product.

quarts (3 liters) water

Your own market

½ medium

onion, roughly sliced

Your own market

garlic cloves, unpeeled

Your own market

Salt to taste

Your own market

1½

lbs (675 g) beef short ribs, cut into small pieces

1½

lbs (675 g) pork knuckles, cut into small pieces

8 small

pieces of chicken

Your own market

1 lb (450 g)

tomatoes, roughly chopped

garlic cloves, roughly chopped

Your own market

thick slices pumpkin or large acorn squash, unpeeled, center strands and seeds included

2 large

ears fresh corn, each cut into 6 pieces

chayotes (about 1½ lbs / 675 g total), peeled and cut into strips

8 oz (225 g)

fresh lima beans in their pods, or shelled fava beans

1 large

scallion, roughly chopped

ripe chilhuacle chiles (Capsicum annuum, Oaxacan variety), left whole

Cilantro, to finish

Your own market

Corn tortillas, to serve

The Method

Bring the water to a simmer in a large, heavy pot. Add the onion, unpeeled garlic, and salt. Add the short ribs and pork knuckles. Maintain a steady simmer — not a boil — and cook for 40 minutes, skimming foam as needed.

Add the chicken pieces and continue cooking for 10 minutes.

In a blender, combine the chopped tomatoes and chopped garlic. Blend until smooth. Pour directly into the pot without straining.

Add the pumpkin or squash slices and the corn. Cook for 10 minutes.

Add the chayote strips, lima or fava beans, and scallion. Continue cooking until all vegetables are nearly tender, about 15 minutes more.

Taste and adjust salt. Add the whole chilhuacle chiles and a handful of cilantro. Finish cooking until the chiles have softened and the broth is deeply flavored, roughly 10 minutes.

From the canon — The chilhuacle — more widely spelled chilhuacle or chilhuacle negro, rojo, or amarillo depending on colour — is a large, leathery dried chile grown in the Ca… Chilhuacle →

Ladle into deep bowls, making sure each serving includes pieces of all three meats and a selection of vegetables. Serve with corn tortillas.

III

Sensory Tests

◇Tilt a ladle of finished broth: it should coat the metal with a faint, oil-sheened film from rendered collagen and fat — a watery, pale broth means the simmer was too short or the bones were lean.

◇Press the side of a whole cooked chilhuacle chile gently with the back of a spoon: it should yield and begin to split without fully disintegrating, releasing a rust-orange blush into the surrounding broth — a chile that holds completely firm was added too late; one that has dissolved entirely was added too early.

◇Taste the broth at the two-hour mark and again at the four-hour mark: the first will be savory but thin at the finish; the second should have a rounding quality on the back of the palate from the gelatin released by the knuckles, with no sharp or raw edges remaining.

◇Where it lives or dies. Chile caldo lives or dies in the timing of the chile addition: the whole chilhuacle chiles must enter the pot late enough to hold their shape and bleed color gradually, but early enough — typically the final forty to fifty minutes — to soften fully and surrender their fruitiness into the broth without cooking down to a bitter, skin-only remnant. Misjudge this window in either direction and the dish loses either its visual identity or its defining flavor register.

IV · Cross-Cuisine Parallels

sancocho-de-res-colombiano — Colombian — Both are large, multi-component bone-in meat broths built around root vegetables and field corn, designed for communal Sunday eating; the structural logic — long simmer, whole vegetables added in sequence, broth as the primary product — is nearly identical, though the chile and regional aromatics distinguish them completely. cocido-madrileno — Spanish (Castilian) — The multi-meat approach — layering cuts of differing fat content and collagen yield to build a single unified broth — mirrors the cocido tradition, and like cocido the broth of chile caldo is often consumed first, separately from the solids it produced. bulalo — Filipino — Bulalo and chile caldo share the primacy of bone marrow and collagen as the broth's structural backbone; both are lowland comfort dishes where the quality of the bones, not the seasoning, is the determining factor in whether the finished liquid has body or remains thin.

Pillar IV

Cross-cuisine parallels are part of membership.

The dishes this one teaches you, across the cuisines — on every recipe.

Enter · from $49 a year